Exploring the Costs of Residential Roof Replacement: Insights from Big Fish Contracting Company

While roofs are built to endure, time and the elements eventually take their toll. If you've started noticing issues like leaks, sagging, or general wear and tear, it's time to consult skilled roofing contractors.


Are you curious about the expense of a new roof?


Let’s break down the factors that influence the cost of roof replacement, weigh the considerations of repair versus replacement, and shed light on the benefits of professional installation compared to DIY attempts.

The Cost Of Residential Roof Replacement | Curious About The Cost Of A New Roof?

The cost of a new roof is typically determined by the following factors:

Type of Roofing Material: Premium materials like slate come with a higher price tag compared to the commonly used asphalt shingles.

Labor Charges: The complexity of the project, proximity to neighboring properties, the time of year, and the associated risks with the installation of your roof all contribute to labor cost variations.

Geographical Location: Local and regional weather conditions will dictate the appropriate roofing type and installation methods, which in turn affect the cost in a way that may be out of your control.

Roof Size: Larger roofs naturally require more materials and labor, leading to higher costs.

Disposal Fees: Properly disposing of old roofing materials may incur additional charges.

Costs Based on Roofing Material:

As a homeowner, your choice of roofing material will play a major role in the overall cost. Common options include asphalt, aluminum, cedar, clay, concrete, copper, rubber, slate, standing seam metal panels, steel shingles, and zinc tiles. 

The Cost Of Residential Roof Replacement | Costs Based On Roofing Materials

Asphalt Shingles: Basic options average at around $4.25 per square foot, while premium choices can reach up to $8.25 per square foot. Most common type of roof that can be installed easily with certified installers.

Aluminum Shingles:
The cheapest of the metal roofing options, aluminum shingle range in cost from $6.25 per square foot to $10.00 per square foot.

Cedar Shingles/Shakes: Cedar shingles fall at mid-range pricing compared to other materials but their cost can vary significantly due to their hand-split nature. Homeowners may expect to pay $6.00 - $10.00 per square foot for cedar shingles.

Clay and Concrete Tiles: Generally pricier compared to most other materials, clay tiles can run a homeowner between $10.00 and $30.00 per square foot.

Copper Tiles: The most expensive option on the list, copper tiles can range from $15.00 - $30.00 per square foot.

Rubber (Flat Roofs): Ethylene propylene diene terpolyme (EPDM) roofing costs between $5.50 and $7.50, but homeowner’s can expect replacement labor expenses to be much higher compared to the rest of the list.

Slate Tiles: Higher end pricing at $15.00 - $30.00 per square foot for materials, but may require additional roof reinforcement and long term maintenance.

Standing Seam Metal Panels: This option costs a homeowner, on average, between $8.00 - $15.00 per square foot.

Steel Shingles: Mid-range pricing within the metal category, steel shingles will cost between $4.50 - $8.50 per square foot.

Zinc Tiles: This type of roofing requires a trained and skilled installer but materials will cost a homeowner $10.00 - $20.00 per square foot.

Labor Expenses:

Labor typically accounts for about 60% of roofing costs. The choice of materials also affects labor costs; for instance, asphalt shingles tend to be more cost-efficient due to their familiarity among contractors. The complexity of the project and its accessibility also contribute to variations in labor costs.

Geographical Location:

Local factors and the cost of living in your area impact roofing expenses. Regions with harsh weather conditions often require higher-quality materials and expert installation, which can increase the overall cost.

Roof Cost Based on House Size:

The size of your home directly influences the required materials and labor. On average, around 80% of asphalt shingle roof replacements fall within the range of $4.50 to $6 per square foot. Here are estimated costs for various home sizes:


1,000 sq ft: $4,500–$6,000

1,500 sq ft: $6,750–$9,000

2,000 sq ft: $9,000–$12,000

2,500 sq ft: $11,250–$15,000

3,000 sq ft: $13,500–$18,000

The size of the roof, measured in squares (100 sq ft areas), directly affects the required time and materials. Roof shape, accessibility, and pitch also impact the overall cost.

The cost of a new roof is typically determined by the following factors:

Type of Roofing Material: Premium materials like slate come with a higher price tag compared to the commonly used asphalt shingles.

Labor Charges: The complexity of the project, proximity to neighboring properties, the time of year, and the associated risks with the installation of your roof all contribute to labor cost variations.

Geographical Location: Local and regional weather conditions will dictate the appropriate roofing type and installation methods, which in turn affect the cost in a way that may be out of your control.

Roof Size: Larger roofs naturally require more materials and labor, leading to higher costs.

Disposal Fees: Properly disposing of old roofing materials may incur additional charges.

Additional Considerations:

The Cost Of Residential Roof Replacement | Additional Considerations When Replacing Your Home's Roof

In addition to materials and labor, several other factors contribute to the total roof replacement cost:


Additional Roofing Projects: Combining roof-related tasks like gutter installation, trim work, skylight replacement, and chimney repairs can lead to cost savings.

Old Roof Removal: Disposing of old roofing materials usually costs between $1 and $5 per square foot.

Underlayment Repair: Necessary repairs to the underlying structure beneath the old roofing.

Roof Features: Elements like chimneys and skylights can add complexity to the project.

Roof Cleaning: Cleaning services may come with additional costs.

Professional Installation vs. DIY:

Undertaking a DIY roof replacement is NOT recommended due to safety concerns and the need for specialized tools. Roofing companies are equipped, trained, and knowledgeable about local building codes, making them the preferred choice.

Maximizing Cost Efficiency in Roof Replacement:

For many homeowners, the prospect of a roof replacement can be financially daunting. However, there are strategies to mitigate the financial impact or distribute the costs over the roof's lifespan.


Prioritize Durable Materials: Familiarize yourself with the range of roofing materials available for replacement. Opt for those that offer durability, reducing the need for frequent replacements during your time in the home.


Regular Inspections and Maintenance: Engage in annual inspection and maintenance routines to identify and address minor issues before they escalate. This proactive approach can save you from premature roof replacements.

Energy-Efficient and Solar Solutions: Explore the potential of solar technology, eligible for a federal tax credit of up to 30%. Similarly, consider energy-efficient roofing materials or the installation of solar shingles to lower your monthly energy bills.

The Lifespan Of Shingle Roofs | Big Fish Cares About Transparency

Leverage Insurance Benefits: Using your home insurance can help offset out-of-pocket costs during roof replacement. However, it's essential to fully understand the process and coverage limits. Review your insurance policy to potentially reduce expenses related to roof replacement. Many roofing companies and contractors have experience working with homeowners and insurance providers.

The Big Fish Contracting Company: Your Trusted Partner

Roof replacement is a significant investment. It is recommended that homeowner’s do not compromise quality to save costs; after all, your roof protects the integrity of your home. Conduct thorough research and obtain estimates from multiple reputable roofing companies like The Big Fish Contracting Company. The longevity of your roof is well worth the investment.


Get in touch with us today for a complimentary consultation, and experience our expertise firsthand. As your reliable roofing partner in Allegheny County, we're here to guide you through the process, ensuring your satisfaction and peace of mind. The Big Fish is committed to delivering top-tier service and achieving optimal results for your home. Choose us as your preferred option for all your roofing needs in the Greater Pittsburgh area.

You might also like

Can You Paint Vinyl Siding? | Insights For Homeowners
02 May, 2024
Can You Paint Vinyl Siding? Insights And Techniques For Homeowners To Consider. What Is Vinyl Siding And Why Its A Popular Choice For Homeowners."
All You Need to Know About Skylights | Illuminate Your Home
02 May, 2024
All You Need to Know About Skylights To Illuminate Your Home. Types of Skylights and Their Features. Benefits of Skylights. Energy Efficient Velux Skylights."
Roof Replacement Costs Pittsburgh | Big Fish Roofing
04 Apr, 2024
Discover affordable roof replacement costs in Pittsburgh with Big Fish Roofing. Get expert advice and multiple quotes for your home.
More Posts
Share by: